Wildwood: extraordinary craft, an unfocused story
Some critics praised Wildwood’s extraordinary craftsmanship while questioning whether its storytelling reached the same standard. Writing for the Associated Press, Mark Kennedy described the film as “technically dazzling” but argued that “the technology outstrips the story.” In Sight and Sound, Leigh Singer similarly praised its visual achievement while questioning its familiar fantasy tropes, overloaded mythology, and lack of narrative breathing room. 
I broadly agree with those reservations. Laika’s command of stop-motion is remarkable, and several ideas have real emotional potential. My difficulties lie in how those ideas are developed: the protagonist’s limited agency, abrupt tonal changes, competing storylines, and an ending that leaves the central theme unresolved.
There is a great deal to learn from this film, particularly for anyone studying how character, structure, and theme work together.
What worked
The craftsmanship
Laika knows how to do stop-motion. The craftsmanship is extraordinary, and the film repeatedly offers images worth appreciating on their own.
The ominous arrival of the crows is particularly effective. The sibling sequence also gives Prue and her brother an affectionate connection, supported by the music. Smaller environmental choices, such as the mansion repurposed as an office, bring charm and specificity to the world.
These achievements deserve recognition. My reservations about the screenplay do not diminish the artistry involved in bringing it to the screen.
The fantasy appeal
For viewers who enjoy fantasy, Wildwood offers plenty: magical forests, talking animals, witches, spells, hidden societies, and an unfamiliar world beyond the ordinary one.
However, abundance does not automatically create originality. Many of these elements are familiar, and their combination did not consistently give me the feeling that I was encountering something distinctive.
There is nothing inherently wrong with familiar ingredients. What matters is the perspective, emotional specificity, and dramatic execution that make them feel fresh. Here, the visual interpretation often feels more distinctive than the underlying storytelling.
The villain’s grief
The strongest emotional premise belongs to the witch: a mother who cannot accept the death of her son and is willing to cause terrible harm to reverse it.
That is a deep, believable source of conflict. Her attempt to reconstruct what she has lost also brings together associations with Frankenstein and Fullmetal Alchemist: grief, attempted restoration, and the consequences of refusing death.
Those comparisons are not accusations of imitation. Stories revisit established premises constantly. Originality can emerge through how a familiar idea is developed.
The bargain with Prue’s parents is especially compelling: the witch will enable them to have their first child, but claim their second. It connects the family’s private history to the central conflict and gives the brother’s abduction a meaningful cause.
I also found potential in the witch’s attachment to Curtis. A grieving mother seeing the possibility of a replacement son creates an emotionally interesting relationship. A specific detail connecting Curtis to her child—a familiar phrase, mannerism, or vulnerability—could have made that attachment even more persuasive.
These are substantial foundations. My concern is that the rest of the film does not consistently organize itself around them.
What didn’t work
1. The opening introduces more disturbance than direction
I am all for a powerful opening. But disturbing material needs a clear dramatic purpose.
The opening involving the boy raises immediate questions about his identity, his condition, and what has happened to him. Its imagery is striking, but I questioned whether every element—including the nudity—deepened the tragedy or primarily intensified the shock.
Creating an unsettling image is relatively straightforward. Making that image necessary to the story requires more: it should establish an emotional relationship, introduce the central conflict, or acquire meaning that justifies its prominence.
Tarzan, for example, opens with danger and loss while establishing the relationships that will define the entire film. Its intensity gives the audience an emotional foundation.
In Wildwood, several mysteries arrive in quick succession: the opening incident, the plant and blood magic, and the sound Prue hears. Multiple mysteries can coexist, but the audience still needs a clear sense of which question matters most.
Before introducing more uncertainty, I would have strengthened the emotional connection to one central question.
2. Prue’s personality and motivation need clearer development
A useful character exercise is to pause a film around the thirty-minute mark and ask the audience to identify three defining traits of its protagonist, supported by specific behavior.
With Prue, I struggled to find a sufficiently clear answer.
Her early behavior establishes defiance, skepticism, and impatience with Curtis. Those qualities could form the beginning of a compelling character. But they need greater specificity and a clearer relationship to her eventual growth.
Her decision to take her brother outside is particularly important. She disobeys an explicit instruction, and the consequences initiate the entire plot.
The issue is not simply that she makes a mistake. Protagonists should be allowed to make mistakes, including selfish ones. The issue is whether we understand the reasoning behind the decision.
If Prue knows there is a credible danger, risking her brother’s safety for an afternoon outside feels inadequately motivated. If she believes her parents’ fears are irrational, the film needs to make that belief convincing from her perspective.
The audience eventually learning why the parents were protective does not, by itself, establish what Prue understood when she disobeyed them.
That distinction matters. A flawed decision can draw us closer to a protagonist when we understand it. Without that understanding, it can simply distance us from her.
3. Prue spends too much of the story requesting solutions
My central concern is Prue’s limited agency.
By approximately forty-five minutes, she has appealed for help from four separate sources: the driver, the birds, the councilors, and the owl. Later, the pattern continues with the mystics and the tree.
Asking for help is not inherently passive. It can express courage, humility, resourcefulness, or an ability to unite others. But those qualities need to be dramatized through the protagonist’s choices.
What does she offer? What does she risk? How does she persuade someone who has a reason to refuse? What does she learn that changes her approach?
Too often, Prue requests assistance and another character supplies the information, transportation, or intervention needed to continue.
Even when she acts physically, those moments arrive after a long stretch in which her influence over events feels limited. Her confrontation with the dog guard is one of the first moments that gives her a more immediate, active role.
The problem is cumulative. Other characters explain the world, discover important information, locate her brother, and arrive to help her. Prue remains the person whose brother is missing, but that does not always make her the person driving the story.
4. Curtis’s storyline competes with the supposed central narrative
The separation of Prue and Curtis creates another structural difficulty.
Parallel storylines can work extremely well. They can reveal contrasting responses to the same problem, develop relationships through separation, or build toward an outcome neither character could achieve alone.
Here, however, Curtis’s storyline increasingly feels like a separate film.
He becomes involved with the witch, the villagers, and the larger conflict while Prue spends significant time imprisoned, receiving explanations, or moving between potential helpers.
When Prue returns home, the imbalance becomes even more apparent. She has left the forest and stepped away from the mission, while Curtis remains where much of the action and conflict are unfolding.
A protagonist can temporarily abandon a quest, but that retreat needs to deepen the central drama. Here, it drains momentum and makes the question of whose story we are watching more difficult to answer.
If this is intended as a shared narrative, both characters need equally deliberate dramatic arcs. If it is primarily Prue’s story, Curtis’s material needs a stronger relationship to her choices and development.
Because the witch has the clearest emotional motivation, I repeatedly found myself wondering whether the film might have been stronger with her tragedy as its organizing center.
5. The tonal changes lack convincing transitions
The film repeatedly moves between horror, comedy, whimsical fantasy, and emotional drama. Those modes can coexist. My difficulty is with how abruptly the film moves between them.
The crows’ arrival is ominous and effective. Almost immediately afterward, a modern, energetic song accompanies the pursuit, shifting the sequence toward a playful action register.
The dramatic situation has not become less frightening: a baby has just been abducted. Yet the music changes how we are being invited to experience it.
Similar shifts recur in the forest. One sequence presents the environment as violent and threatening; another offers enchanting scenery, upbeat music, and an owl making jokes.
The film does not always give the audience enough time—or a sufficient dramatic reason—to move from one emotional state to the next.
The scene in the witch’s house presents the same problem through dialogue. Prue arrives suspicious and confrontational, effectively telling the witch that she recognizes the performance and will not be deceived. Shortly afterward, she moves into sympathetic condolences about the witch’s son.
Compassion and suspicion can coexist. But the transition needs a believable trigger: something Prue sees, learns, or recognizes that changes her response.
Without that bridge, the scene feels as though her attitude changes to accommodate the next emotional beat.
This reminds me of my difficulty with Twisters: sequences that present danger as exhilarating recreation sit beside scenes emphasizing its devastating human cost. The challenge is making those perspectives feel connected through the characters’ experience.
In Wildwood, I too often felt the change in presentation before I understood the emotional transition.
6. Obstacles and solutions do not follow consistent rules
Several escape sequences weaken their own stakes.
Prue is taken into custody, yet the apparent accessibility of the room and the guards’ distractibility make the confinement difficult to take seriously.
The dog guards are initially intimidating, but ordinary canine impulses can quickly undermine them: chasing a tail or responding to “fetch.”
That can work as a joke. Once it works as a solution, however, it becomes part of the story’s logic. If Prue has learned an effective way to distract a guard, subsequent encounters need to account for that knowledge.
Otherwise, the guards’ competence seems to change according to whether a scene needs danger or an escape.
Similarly, falling from a roof and landing on transportation that can carry her onward feels convenient rather than earned.
Chance can complicate a character’s situation or create an opportunity. Repeatedly using it to resolve immediate problems reduces the significance of the protagonist’s decisions.
7. Too many scenes repeat a function without advancing the story
The forest contains numerous encounters, creatures, institutions, and explanations. But introducing something new is not always the same as moving the narrative forward.
A useful editing exercise is to remove a scene and ask what changes.
Does the protagonist make a consequential decision? Does a relationship shift? Is essential information revealed? Does an earlier event acquire a new meaning?
For example, if the main contribution of an extended bird encounter is establishing that Prue is an outsider, could that information be delivered more efficiently elsewhere?
Likewise, repeated scares eventually stop developing the forest. Once we understand that it is dangerous, another threatening creature needs to do more than reinforce the same point.
The mystics raise a similar question. What distinct dramatic function does the encounter serve beyond adding another unsuccessful request for help?
This is where a lengthy film can still feel underdeveloped: considerable time is spent introducing material, while the central character’s motivation and growth remain comparatively thin.
8. Important emotional turns need stronger preparation
Several developments have potential but need more support.
Curtis risks his life for Prue, yet his early characterization emphasizes his talkativeness and social awkwardness. His courage would feel more grounded if the film planted an earlier choice that revealed his loyalty, values, or willingness to act despite fear.
Prue’s mother’s desperation to have a child also needs sufficient emotional context. The bargain is consequential enough that the audience should understand what makes her willing to accept an extraordinary risk.
Prue’s belief in the witch’s account of her brother’s death raises another issue. Having been warned about the witch—and having initially challenged her dishonesty—what makes Prue accept this particular claim?
Grief, fear, and manipulation could explain it. But the scene needs to show the pressure overcoming her skepticism.
The tree’s eventual change of mind similarly requires a clear dramatic cause. What does Prue say or do that changes the situation? Why does the appeal succeed now?
These are the moments where the screenplay needs especially precise cause and effect, because they determine major changes in direction.
9. The ending does not fully resolve the theme
The witch’s storyline suggests a powerful theme: the destruction caused by refusing to accept loss.
However, Prue’s storyline complicates that interpretation without fully clarifying it.
Near the end, her father expresses the idea that sometimes we need to know when to let go. Prue responds, in effect, that she is glad she did not—because her persistence helped bring her brother home.
There is a meaningful distinction available here. Trying to resurrect someone who has died is different from refusing to abandon someone who can still be saved.
That distinction could give the film a strong thematic conclusion: love requires both persistence and an acceptance of reality, and maturity involves learning when each is necessary.
But the film needs to dramatize that difference clearly.
The witch’s death does not require a redemption arc. A tragic ending can communicate a theme just as effectively. What matters is whether the resolution reveals the meaning of her choices and connects them to the protagonist’s growth.
Prue’s final appeal to the forest also returns to the agency problem. A resolution based on asking for help can be powerful if it demonstrates a developed ability to listen, connect, persuade, or unite. Here, I wanted a clearer connection between what she has learned and why the forest responds.
As a result, the film closes with several potentially meaningful ideas—grief, belief, persistence, growing up, and letting go—without bringing them into a sufficiently clear relationship.
Wildwood contains the foundations of a powerful story, especially in the witch’s grief and the bargain that connects her to Prue’s family. For me, the screenplay needed a clearer dramatic center: a protagonist whose decisions shape events, supporting storylines that strengthen that journey, and an ending that turns its thematic possibilities into a convincing emotional resolution.

You may also like

↑Back to Top